“Socialist” propaganda (with biblical support!)

The other day, a colleague called me a socialist when he found out I plan on voting for a democrat this year. “So you’re okay with your hard-earned money turning into handouts?” he asked incredulously. “You don’t think you have a right to keep what you earn?” Several others in the room piped in, ranting about the evils of universal healthcare and the welfare system.

I was doing some design work for a conservative evangelical organization, and I was surprised by how aggressively this group argued for the moral superiority of Republicanism. (After touting his position on the sanctity of life, one suggested that Ted Kennedy’s brain tumor was a favor from God.)

Something isn’t right here.

I’ve been a democrat for all of four months now, and what has surprised me the most is how passionately conservative evangelicals oppose social reforms that benefit the poor. I understand why Christians have moral objections to abortion, and I know a lot of good Christian people who have very good reasons for voting Republican ….but since when is laissez-faire economics a biblical principle?

Honestly, if you were looking, I think you could find more Bible verses “supporting” communism than capitalism. When you consider the division of land in ancient Israel, God’s instructions concerning the year of jubilee, the sabbatical year, and the laws about gleaning, as well as the description of the early Church in which participants “had everything in common,” you could make the case that the ideal society is one in which wealth is shared.

Of course, such a way of life is impossible to apply literally to a democratic government, but I think these passages reveal what the rest of Scripture most certainly confirms: that God cares deeply for the poor.

There are around 300 verses in the Bible that address the poor and social justice. Many of them warn against wealth, particularly when it is withheld from the needy.

In fact, throughout the Bible we read stories of God’s displeasure with entire nations that do not care for the poor.  Amos predicted that the northern kingdom of Israel would be destroyed in the midst of a time of prosperity and economic growth, in part because of its neglect of the poor. He saw that the rich “trample the head of the poor into the dust of the earth” (2:7). He criticized the lifestyle of the rich, which was built on the oppression of the poor (6:1-7), and was particularly dismayed that the poor had no hope because the rich bribed the judges (5:10-15).

The destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah had as much to do with neglect of the poor as it did with sexual immorality. In Ezekiel 16 God says, “Behold this was the guilt of your sister Sodom: she and her daughters had pride, surfeit of food, and prosperous ease, but did not aid the poor and needy…”

When it comes time for Jesus to “judge the nations,” the gospels reveal that judgment will be based on treatment of “the least of these”-the hungry, the imprisoned, the thirsty, the naked.

I’ve heard a lot of people express concern that God will destroy the U.S. for its sexual immorality. I’ve never heard anyone warn that He might destroy it for its inequality.

Overall, I think America does a decent job of caring for the poor both here and abroad. I feel strongly that all people should be able to afford basic healthcare, that all children should have access to a good education, and that government subsidized food and housing should be available for those who need it. I know that these systems can be abused and that there will always be need for reform, but I think that they represent Christian ideals.

Now, I’m not suggesting that it is somehow more Christ-like to vote for a candidate who supports universal healthcare and who will increase taxes for the wealthy. Last time I checked, Jesus wasn’t a democrat or a republican. However, I think it’s important for Christians to respect one another’s varying interpretations of how best to apply biblical principals to government. Evangelicals in particular need to be careful of embracing one party’s ideology in its entirety. 

It’s frustrating to be called a “socialist” when you’re honestly trying to faithfully follow Christ’s leading. Oh, and I also prefer not be called a “baby-killer.” (As you might have guessed, being a so-called liberal hasn’t been as easy as I thought it would be!)


Aubrey
Comment
Re: “Socialist” propaganda (with biblical support!)
Reply #1 on : Sun June 08, 2008, 02:25:07
I really liked this post!

I don't have any other comments because you already said pretty much everything I was going to say...
Laurie
Comment
Re: “Socialist” propaganda (with biblical support!)
Reply #2 on : Sun June 08, 2008, 14:36:34
Thanks Rachel!

For me being called a "socialist" isn't really frustrating--it's more annoying that the word is used as a pejorative. I guess it's a cold war-era hangover. Socialism is simply a way of organizing various aspects of society. Some people think it's a good way of organizing things, others don't.

Also, I have to take a little bit of issue with your thought that America does a decent job of taking care of the poor abroad, given that the way our society is constructed means we benefit off the poverty of others. Many, if not most, of the products that we buy are made by people who do not receive a living wage, or certainly not a wage that allows them a lifestyle anywhere close to what even the poorer members of our society have. And so much of the stuff we buy we don't need. Not to play down the very real financial struggle and poverty that exists in our own country or to say that this is a black-and-white, cut-and-dried issue. I don't know that America as a nation has some responsibility to take all the world's poor out of poverty, but how we live at the top of the world economic heap is something to consider, especially as Christians. Like you said, God certainly seems quite concerned with the plight of the poor.
Paul
Comment
Sojourners
Reply #3 on : Sun June 08, 2008, 17:45:09
Rachel,

Love the book title and the ideas behind it. I am guessing you have already heard of these people but are you familiar with Sojourners? I think they would represent your positions well especially as a person of faith. Likewise, you might like the website, faithfuldemocrats.com.
I don't envy the challenge you experience in trying to be a Christian and a Democrat in rural TN but we always have books and the web to encourage and support us.

Paul Miller
Mitch
Comment
The Poor
Reply #4 on : Sun June 08, 2008, 18:57:53
I am certainly one that does not favor government mandated socialism. However this is an excellent post that challenges the blind spot of our wealthy and generally self-indulgent society and church. The helpless and hopeless are clearly near to the heart of God and a major litmus test for us in measuring whether we are walking with God. May God grant us the courage to care for the widow, orphan, poor, and helpless in our communities as we declare the Gospel to them.
Last Edit: June 09, 2008, 10:47:00 by admin  
Laurie
Comment
thanks Mitch
Reply #5 on : Sun June 08, 2008, 20:58:40
This is such an important point:

"The helpless and hopeless are clearly near to the heart of God and a major litmus test for us in measuring whether we are walking with God."
Micah
Comment
Happy Birthday, Rachel!
Reply #6 on : Sun June 08, 2008, 22:47:24
That's all.
kristen
Comment
Re: “Socialist” propaganda (with biblical support!)
Reply #7 on : Wed June 11, 2008, 12:58:34
i too enjoyed reading your post and agree that the ways in which conservative religion and conservative politics have been combined are strange. :) stick with it and you will continue to find more politically liberal christians around you. and you may just give them the courage to speak up.

i would also agree with laurie's reservations about the job america does with/for the poor, both at home and abroad. we do okay but could do so much more. i support fair and just trade, rather than free trade. after all, nothing in this world is free.
Kristen Covington
Comment
Kudos.
Reply #8 on : Wed June 18, 2008, 16:46:35
I'm just back from being overseas and haven't caught up yet, but I'll give you kudos on this blog. Also, as a side note--being a socialist isn't some foreign, scary thing. We're all part of a partially-socialist government. We have socialized education and a socialized postal service. This may be stretching just a bit, but our public library system might even be considered socialist. While we have other aspects that are government-supported, these three seem to be fairly close to 100% supported by the public. I don't here many people arguing that we should completely privatize education, mail services, and libraries. We better watch out for big, bad socialism because our education, mail service, and local libraries are going to get us!
Kristen Covington
Comment
Sad.
Reply #9 on : Thu June 19, 2008, 15:22:59
Hear, not here. Shameful.
Jason
Comment
Poor???Values???
Reply #10 on : Wed July 02, 2008, 11:50:31
For anyone who believes that America has poor people compared to any other country, is misguided. Even the poor in America are rich is most of Africa. In respect to the rest of the world, America takes very good care of their poor. But I will say, the reason the government feels they must provide for the poor is because our churches have slacked on their calling. "Pure and undefiled religion in the sight of our God and Father is this: to visit orphans and widow in their distress." James 1:27.

About whether a Christian should vote dem. or rep. I stand on this principle...when I stand before God one day...will he be able to say well done good and faithful servant in regards to my political invovlement. I can't see myself before God justifying my support of a candidate that will activily support abortion.

The moral issues for me far out weigh the social issues in the selection of a president, because the moral issues of the DNC are wicked in the eyes of God is can not support them.

Write a comment

  • Required fields are bold and marked with *.

If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code.
Security Code:*
 

get an account to edit future comments
and remove the captcha security code